LED vs. Incandescent: The Great Christmas Light Debate

There’s something magical about seeing your house twinkle with Christmas lights during the holidays. It’s as if you're wrapping your little part of the world in a warm, festive hug. But when it comes to choosing between LED and incandescent Christmas lights, especially for outdoor use, the decision can feel as complicated as untangling last year’s light strands. Let me guide you through my own journey with both types of lights, from battling unruly cords to the final, satisfying switch on.

I remember the year I decided to go all out for the holidays. Picture this: icicle lights trimming the house, a reindeer or two in the yard, and of course, a Santa Claus with his sleigh. I dashed to the store, excitement bubbling, and faced the first hurdle of my festive adventure: the vast array of lighting options.

Understanding the Basics: What's the Difference?

  • Energy Efficiency: LEDs use up to 90% less energy than incandescent lights. This was a game changer for me because it meant I could go all out without fearing my electricity bill in January!
  • Longevity: LED lights often tout a staggering lifespan—up to 50,000 hours compared to 1,000 hours for their incandescent cousins. Last year, I didn’t have to replace a single LED bulb, whereas the year before, I was swapping out dead incandescents almost weekly.
  • Durability: LED bulbs are more resistant to breakage since they're made with epoxy lenses, not glass. This was a big plus for me, especially after that windy storm last December left my delicate incandescent bulbs in shambles.
  • Cost: Initial cost for LEDs is higher, but they save money in the long run. Trust me, the upfront investment pays off.

With these points in mind, I found myself leaning towards LEDs, but I was curious about how each type actually performs in the wild—aka, my front yard. (energy.gov)

Personal Test: Setting Up the Lights

Last year, I decided to do a small test. I decorated one side of my porch with LEDs and the other with incandescents. The setup itself was the first test. The LEDs were lightweight and less prone to tangling, a relief because I could still feel the ghost of last year’s frustrations untangling the heavy, prone-to-knots incandescent strings.

The real test came with the weather. We had everything from snow to a minor hailstorm, and the difference was clear: the LED side endured without a single blackout, while the incandescent side needed regular bulb replacements.

Brightness and Color Quality

The bright, vibrant output of LEDs is pretty impressive. They offer a sharper, more intense color which made my home look like it was straight out of a Christmas card. The incandescents, while they have a softer, warmer glow that many might find nostalgic, were noticeably dimmer. This could be a personal preference, but for me, the vividness of LEDs won out.

I also experimented with multicolored strands. LEDs provide consistent color, while incandescent lights can seem uneven if you’re looking close enough. So, if you're a perfectionist like me, LEDs might save you from squinting across the lawn, wondering why one bulb seems off.

The Verdict From a Financial Perspective

I crunched some numbers to see how the costs panned out. Assuming an average house requires around 20 strands of lights, the cost of running incandescent lights for a month would be significantly higher than running LEDs. Not to mention the replacement costs for the incandescents. My little experiment confirmed that LEDs were more economical over time, despite the higher initial investment.

Are LEDs Perfect?

No product is without faults, and LEDs do have a couple. They’re more expensive upfront, and they can flicker when dimmed improperly or paired with the wrong hardware. Plus, the light can be almost too harsh for some, particularly in warm white. Thankfully, newer models have improved with softer tones and adjustable settings.

Final Thoughts: Why I Stick with LEDs for Outdoor Christmas Lighting

Reflecting on my experiences and the facts, LEDs are my choice for outdoor Christmas lights. They’re durable, bright, energy-efficient, and although the initial cost is higher, they prove more economical in the long run. Whether it’s lowering my carbon footprint or just keeping my house merry and bright, LED lights meet all my holiday needs.

If you’re planning your holiday display, consider what’s most important for your celebration. Is it the nostalgic glow, the cost savings, or perhaps the environmental impact? Whatever you choose, happy decorating, and may your holidays sparkle just the way you dream!

Takeaways for a Brighter Holiday

  • Consider longevity and overall cost savings when choosing between LEDs and incandescents.
  • Think about the environmental impact—LEDs are more energy-efficient.
  • Don’t forget about the aesthetics; choose the type of light that matches the holiday spirit you want to create.
  • Always check the weather durability if you’re decorating outdoors. LEDs often have better resistance to harsh conditions.

Decorating for Christmas is a cherished tradition in many homes, and choosing the right lights can set the tone for your holiday season. From my festive fumbles to fine-tuning the setup, I’ve learned that a little planning and understanding can lead to a dazzling display. Here's to a bright, beautiful holiday season!

Tagged in:

Product Reviews & Comparisons